top of page

AYU WHITMORE

IDENTITY, PLACE & CULTURE

BRAINSTORMING

I want to first consider what aspects of “Identity, Place & Culture” already exist inside my practice, and what new territory this project could let me push it into. In second year I looked into how people are formed by places that aren't straightforwardly geographical. I, and many other young people, grew up extremely online, and so our feeds and platform based communities have functioned as environments in which identity and belief are formulated around. I've investigated niche communities partly because I'm interested in how people come to believe and belong. Overwhelmingly my work has concerned how identity is constructed through environments that aren't conventionally understood as places.​​​​

​​

​

Screenshot 2026-10-02 131616.png

The Constructing the Unseen brief asks to dream up and create an entirely imaginary place that reflects personal, cultural, or societal ideals, fears, or aspirations. This place may be utopian, dystopian, surreal, or ambiguous.

​

I'm interested in imaginary place less as fictional landscape and more as a way of visualising systems of reality and belief that we inhabit but can't fully comprehend.

Building on my interest in how abstract structures shape everyday experience,​ this project could explore how we construct explanatory frameworks, whether religion or mythology or mathematics or conspiracy, to make sense of and locate ourselves within it. Why do we seek to reveal an invisible order beneath reality, and what conditions produce this desire for transcendence? I'm however conscious of avoiding reductive comparisons that overlook the distinct histories, purposes and epistemological foundations of these frameworks.

We use existing systems of meaning to make ourselves intelligible. Why does this particular society demand that individuals continually define, "understand" and communicate who they are? What explanatory frameworks become attractive under contemporary conditions of alienation, individualisation and commodification? Existential questions of "Who am I?" and "What is reality?" become structurally similar. We construct models of both.​​​​​​​​​​

Despite all this ideation I don't intend to settle on a single conceptual framework just yet. In second year I was encouraged to approach early project development more freely, as my tendency to overconceptualise limited my experimentation. For now, these questions provide direction within the themes while leaving room to explore different possibilities.

​

Page IPC.avif
Page IPC 2.avif

We went to Yorkshire sculpture park. My observational sketches really reflect my anxieties about entering the third year. They offer little beyond literal representation. ​

Body Mapping

I was introduced to the concept of body mapping, a psychological exercise that, 

in therapy and somatic practice, helps connect mind and body by exploring how emotions manifest physically.

 

We were given questions to answer that prompted us to think about what kind of artists we are, mentally and physically. It was a helpful exercise that made me reflect more on my aspirations and feelings, the weight I carry and the stress that physically manifests in relation to my practice.

​I was drawn to the outcomes of my contemporaries. One person ignored the sculptures altogether, instead photographing and collaging interesting natural textures, while another simply filmed the intimate experience of walking around the park with their friends. Both captured something beyond what was immediately visible (I realise how much I still have to learn about documenting journeys meaningfully.) 

Anyway this leftist rabbit hole is relevant to my exploration of identity because it addresses how it can be lived experience, cultural signifiers and commodification of the self. I wanted to explore these different representations of myself through a body map. Being that identity is increasingly mediated through images (think the meticulous curation of an Instagram dump, carefully constructed to appear effortless), I trawled through my camera roll as though collecting evidence of my own existence. Screenshots, memes, mundane candids—anything that resonated, however trivial. 

trans girl suicide museum.avif

I found myself returning to Hannah Baer's Trans girl suicide museum when thinking of what this project was asking of me. This book doesn't belong to a single theoretical tradition, both memoir and cultural criticism with memes peppered in between. In a 2021 interview, Baer described the museum metaphor central to her book as a way of organising experience into something impersonal, and discusses how social hostility can produce an obsessive need to understand and explain one's own identity.​

"[People are] just trying to navigate a culture that tells us personal identity matters a lot, consumer identity matters a lot. A huge part of my experience of affluent white American culture, since my childhood, was being expected to define myself as an individual, through my dress and taste and academic performance and literally any other choice I made. Like making a character at the beginning of an RPG. Public symbols as everything, starter pack meme as everything. And I think this context of constructed self-hood in alienated consumerism is conducive to anxiety [...] A lot of young people—and I struggled with this too— want queerness or transness to answer the existential question, “who am I,” when in fact the construction of that question in alienated consumer capitalism is basically unanswerable in a meaningful personal way."

Baer challenges the expectation that people can provide complete, transparent explanations of who they are. Our identities emerge through histories and social norms that precede our ability to understand them. We cannot give a complete account of ourselves because we are never entirely the authors of ourselves.​​​​​

She also touches upon something similar to Édouard Glissant's concept of the right to opacity that challenges the demand that others must become completely intelligible according to somebody else's system before they can be recognised or accepted. Understanding another person shouldn't require reducing them to categories our particular society recognises. Baer addressed this more specifically in relation to her transgender identity: "If we lived in a culture with a higher tolerance for ambiguity, rather than obsession with measurement, fixed identity, and knowability, transition wouldn’t be so confounding to people, and the process might be more normal. [...] What are you, trans people get asked. Where are you from, people of color get asked. White supremacist capitalism wants to make a map of everything, and then monetize the ways that things move around on the map."​

IMG_3031_edited.jpg

Meme from @Baseballscenefromtwilight on Instagram

Laser print 1_1.avif

I printed these images and transferred them onto watercolour paper using acrylic medium. Rubbing away the paper revealed imperfect, hazy prints. This was particularly effective with photographs of my younger self, where the faded quality echoed the unreliability of memory.

​I thought about creating a satirical animation featuring archetypal student socialists who are passionately committed to changing the world but become so absorbed in debating and correcting one another that they lose sight of the purpose of their organisation. We are stuck under a consumer capitalism where the relational processes through which we become ourselves are increasingly organised around legibility, categorisation, and the performance of individuality, and so while their political convictions are sincere, their collective identity becomes something to perform and defend rather than a means of achieving anything.

​

This was inevitably going to be self-referential. I didn't want to fall into the lazy conclusion that young leftists are simply privileged hypocrites, or that political conviction is inherently embarrassing. Their earnestness, however insufferable, is also what makes them hopeful. Rather than resolving the story through some revelation, I wanted to construct a world that literalised the absurdity of their debating. 

leftist infighting.avif

It actually recalls Mark Fisher's divisive 2013 essay Exiting the Vampire Castle. While I find his dismissal of feminists' critiques of sexism within the left rather brocialist, I agree with with his criticism of political purity as an obstacle to collective action.

In an age of constant online scrutiny, fear of complicity can produce paralysis rather than praxis (we even dance less in clubs now!). As Asam Ahmad argues in (deleted article) A Note on Call-Out Culture, reducing people to their positions of privilege risks replacing systemic critique with individual moral judgement. Political identity becomes a substitute for political action, where appearing radical matters more than producing change. Ironically, these internal divisions can serve the very capitalist structures such politics seek to challenge. 

Philosofoid 1.PNG
placeholder 1.PNG

I ditched this idea but I still think it was a productive tangent having helped me develop visuals that were more hopeful, more unity based.

The Self Is Not Enough

Hideaki Anno’s cult classic anime Neon Genesis Evangelion was formative to my 14-year-old, cringe, identity-questioning self. I wanted to revisit a sequence from its final episode, Take Care of Yourself, to examine how abstract psychological concepts can be translated into visual storytelling.

​​

The sequence takes place during the Human Instrumentality Project, an attempt to merge humanity into a single collective consciousness. 

Shinji finds himself in a featureless void, supposedly possessing absolute freedom, yet without anything to define himself against, this freedom is indistinguishable from nonexistence. When a ground and horizon appear, he gains a point of reference but loses the ability to fly. The paradox is that the boundaries restricting our freedom also make identity possible. The self is not an independent, fixed essence but something constituted through relationships with others.​

​

Anno literalises this throughout Evangelion. The A.T. Fields, protective barriers in battle, also represent the psychological boundaries separating individuals. They protect the self while simultaneously isolating it, embodying the show's recurring hedgehog's dilemma: our desire for intimacy versus our fear of being hurt. Rather than merely explaining psychological conflict, Anno gives it a physical form. This is what interests me about Constructing the Unseen: using visual storytelling to make abstract relationships tangible.

Sachiel field.png

Neon Genesis Evangelion

IMG_3148.avif

But why am I, someone partial to Marxism, so invested in this existentialist navel-gazing? My interest lies partly in questioning its limits. Under neoliberalism, structural contradictions are frequently reframed as personal shortcomings to be managed through introspection and self-improvement. But at what point does "understanding" ourselves become a distraction from changing the conditions that shape us?​
​​

While Shinji's journey ultimately concerns self-acceptance, I want to move beyond individual introspection towards the social conditions shaping identity. If we are products of structures we did not choose, how might we collectively transform them?

​

This brings me back to Mark Fisher, particularly his writing on lost futures in Capitalist Realism and Ghosts of My Life. Fisher examines how capitalism constrains not only our material lives but our capacity to imagine alternatives. Young people's idealism is routinely dismissed as something they'll outgrow upon entering the 'real world', echoing Thatcher's infamous 'there is no alternative'. Even ecological catastrophe becomes easier to accept than fundamental systemic change.

IMG_3022_edited.jpg

Meme from @memecitytrick on Instagram

Fisher's 'slow cancellation of the future' concerns the diminishing sense of cultural novelty, as alternative movements are repeatedly repackaged or absorbed into capitalism. This cultural stagnation interests me alongside the erosion of communal spaces and possibilities for collective life.


Recently I attended a screening in Nottingham, We Are Making a Film About Mark Fisher, which helped crystallise this direction. The film's method of distribution was compelling. The directors actually rejected releasing it online, instead organising in-person screenings internationally to encourage discussion. The audience becomes part of the project: 'We are making a film about Mark Fisher and now that you are watching, so are you.'

There is value in this approach, a film concerned with the loss of collective possibility becomes an occasion for people to gather and participate. It demonstrates how art can do more than represent an idea; it can create the conditions for experiencing it. This is the direction I want to take my own work: combining the emotional, surreal visual language that drew me to Evangelion with Fisher's questions about cultural stagnation, collective identity and the futures we struggle to imagine. "It is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism."

UNRAVELING

In session we discussed our professional trajectories, the universality in the fact we will go on difficult journeys in our illustrative careers. We were asked to create a quick illustration representing our BIGGEST DREAM.​​​

​

Summer Eternal is a game studio/art collective I've followed (stalked) since their 2024 manifesto which promises to "unite world-class artists and creatives in a truly independent game studio which will always prioritize artistic integrity over personal comfort, profit margin, short term interests and Big Tech profit-bubbles." Their first anthology release included a discussion with science-fiction writer Ted Chiang​, in which they discuss how the word "utopia" is used to describe a prospective socialist future being impossible to achieve because it seeks a sort of impossible perfection. As Chiang says, "there is no society where everyone is happy, but we can imagine a society that responds functionally when some of its members are unhappy rather than ignoring them." 

​​

To reject nihilism, to reject the pessimism and defeatism of older generations, to imagine alternatives. That is my dream. Fisher thought artists were never given the assets and opportunity to bring forth the new, but Summer Eternal attempts to defy it.

Inspired by Summer Eternal's ethos, I also quite liked the quote they have as a slogan "A single spark, a prairie fire." It brings to mind revolutionary imagery (I believe the quote is a rephrasing of a Mao Zedong quote) and I so I illustrated a simple image of grasses on fire.

​

We were then instructed to hand over our drawings and watch them be destroyed. Resilience is needed in a journey that will be tumutlous and unpredictable. Here we had our work taken out of our control, and were asked to make something new from the scraps.

A prairie fire.png
1792357720216-6e9626ca-5ab9-4ab4-a116-4120611dea04_1.jpg
Weaving.avif
IMG_3169.avif

The first thing I did was experiment with weaving the shredded pieces. When I created a pattern I liked I then scanned it in and digitally edited it to fill certain blank squares and give the impression of fire. It created a fun kind of graphic poster design.

​

I thought to utilise more of the scraps and the motif of fire I had been playing with. I assembled cut strips into a house like the Summer Eternal logo, and took a lighter to it, scanning the progressive burning of the paper. 

IMG_3159.avif
Teabag tests.avif
Teabag tests prints.avif
Untitled1465_20261023231259.avif

I also reused the original image (editing it to increse contrast and make the print clearer) to experiment with a printing technique where I took used teabags, emptied and dried them, and printed onto the teabags over the paper. This created interesting textures on both the paper below and actual teabag paper. I think it would make for an interesting animation technique. 

IMG_3179.avif
Collograph cutouts 2.avif
THE LOST PRESENT

I (a humble zoomer) have grown up in a world where alternatives seem impossible, having never experienced the futures that Fisher described as lost in Ghosts of My Life. His account of cultural stagnation emerged from a particular historical experience, the transition from twentieth-century modernist experimentation to twenty-first-century exhaustion. 
Post-punk, once a radically innovative working class movement, was repackaged into derivative, corporate-friendly, apolitical indie like Kaiser Chiefs, a fake underground offering no friction or resistance. Microgenres and aesthetics like Vaporwave similarly recycled the corporate muzak of the 1980s and 90s, evoking a pre-crisis consumer utopia that never really existed. The irony is that the 90s were already deeply commercialised, but compared to the post-2008 era, they seemed to offer a certain innocence and optimism about technological and social progress. Even rebellion had become another marketable spectacle, anticipated and sold back to its audience.

 

So what does a post-crisis generation have to be nostalgic for? Many of us spent formative years in lockdown, and we haven't necessarily experienced the cultural optimism or radical experimentation whose disappearance Fisher mourned. But drawing on Derrida, hauntology isn't restricted to firsthand memories. Unrealised possibilities can still haunt those who never experienced them. ​

image.png
Screenshot 2026-11-03 041354.png

Future Perspective (1982) Keith Mansfield / Richard Elen

image.png
image.png
downloadgram.org_838645639_18655140853005471_7974300035586974676_n.jpg

Gen Z has its own trends of collective nostalgia, such Y2K and 2016 aesthetics, fandom spaces before mainstream commercialisation, the 'Millennial Optimism' trend which looks back on the early 2010s as a period of creativity and pre-doomscrolling innocence. Even online dissident countercultures recycle the language and mythology of old forums like 4chan, with younger users adopting identities from communities they never experienced the hayday of. These revivals often reconstruct entire periods through selective images and second-hand memories, reducing the past to Pinterest boards. Much of what gets romanticised was already commercialised and derivative in its own time, but the idea that the internet and social media could democratise talent and open up new paths into creative work was everywhere. After all, as Adam Curtis might argue, one of late capitalism’s greatest tricks is convincing us that self-expression itself can become a viable economic model.

​

What actually interests me is what's missing beyond the aesthetics: less algorithmically motivated online communities, cultural experimentation outside platforms, a sense of optimism about technological and social progress. Gen Z also seems haunted by what could have been. Even the formative experiences lost to the pandemic. (Look into media around this).

 

This differs from the specific cultural losses Fisher identified, but perhaps the endless recycling is itself symptomatic of the stagnation he described. We seem increasingly unable to imagine a future that isn't assembled from fragments of the past. The nostalgia isn't necessarily for what those periods actually were, but for what they seemed to promise.

Nostalgia and liminality manifests as a melancholic longing for a future that our grandparents or parents believed in (e.g., mid-century public infrastructure, utopian sci-fi, or old analog media) that was subsequently dismantled by neoliberalism.​

​

Today the future does not exist except as the reconfiguration of the past; ghosts of the past haunt the present via remixes, sequels, and remakes.

downloadgram.org_541444814_18068535683467283_2160201156823308138_n.jpg

@doomscroll_forever on instagram

downloadgram.org_540630072_18068535764467283_8267137189943628122_n.jpg

@doomscroll_forever on instagram

Old internet nostalgia 

Yaoi paddle filter.png
Yaoi paddle stickers.png
Yaoi paddle.png
mlp sh alt 2.avif
Collograph cutouts 1_edited.jpg
little girl alt.avif

Macintosh's, New Balance's 70s, 80s communication. David, one of the most well-known protein bar brands among Gen Z, features some of the simplest and most retro branding around. 

Serif Populism -- leaning into 80s nostalgia while perpetuating Republican conservatism, false AI humanism and diet culture.

image.png

1984 ad from Apple

downloadgram.org_611779516_17923034292211829_2212809127078068110_n.jpg

Contemporary artist Simon Denny argues that right-wing techno-libertarians and modern defense contractors are actively co-opting art history and avant-garde aesthetics to normalize warfare and rebrand militarism as heroic cultural progress. 

image.png
Thiel.png
Thiel alt.png

The format of an interactive world allows for spatial experiments I would otherwise only be able to experiment with if I had physical space, e.g. an installation (which I don't)​

Neon Genesis Evangelion is relevant structurally to my idea of an unseen world: a physical environment collapsing; conventional narrative collapsing; characters existing within radically abstract psychological space; voices and interrogation interrupting. Evangelion is a case study for what happens when place becomes psyche. 

​

media theory- the medium is the message - that the physical and technical features of a medium (like print, television, or the internet) have a greater social impact than the specific content they carry - (frankfurt school/chomsky influence) views media as commercial industries that manufacture consent, maintain power structures, and distract the public with superficial entertainment

If you want to feel the lost futures you actually just need to exist in the real world. But the real world = digital mediation (or phone, to be crudely simple)

Let's go back to where we weren't lost or stagnant -- we imagined flip-phones, exciting 90s tech 

 

I must ​distil the point: THINK ABOUT WHAT YOU WANT TO GET SOMEONE TO REALISE with this game. e.g. I want to get people to understand what is missing. Do I want the player to leave feeling that something has been taken from them, or feeling that something remains possible for them to reclaim? The first might produce an experience of capitalist realism; the second toward Fisher's acid communism and the recovery of collective possibility.​​​​

 

This all leads to lost futures. Its a series of things as a reaction - it is ALL ABOUT CONTROL​​​

​

"Computer games are designed to level up inside so you don't have to do it within society because there's less space to do that"

In this sense my world could be escapism skewed (As meaningful forms of advancement and collective participation become more difficult to access, digital environments offer increasingly measurable and accessible substitutes for achievement). The thing it conveys is urgency and learning to exist within the real world. A generation accustomed to environments in which agency is simulated, measured and rewarded, while the material conditions of agency outside those environments deteriorate.

​

What is the antidote?

The game itself becomes an investigation of why the player wanted to escape into it in the first place.

​

Write down takes on the antidote to *not living in the real world* and *how we got to the position of lost futures*.

Focus on one or a couple of them - there isn't a single thing that will fix everything

  • ​Spectres of Marx (Deconstruction in a Nutshell breaks it down)

  • Hauntology Now

  • The Metaphysics of Crackle. Goes over the connection between afrofutursim, postmodernity and a stolen future of eternal displacement.

  • Acid Horizon podcast

  • Gardens: An Essay on the Human Condition.

  • R.U.R by Capek

  • the dialectic of enlightenment (how stories and myths can haunt the present)

  • Hypernormalisation, The trap: what happened to our dream of freedom. Century of the self and Freud's fear of the subconscious 

  • ​Adorno’s The Culture Industry

  • "Babbling Corpse" Grafton Tanner explores vaporware music as an exposition of hauntology and capitalism

  • ​Hauntology: Theorizing the Spectral in Psychological Anthropology" (2019) - Bryon Good 

  • podcast called Material Girls (formerly witch please) episode on Hauntology

  • Simon Reynolds retromania

  • Bifo Berardi "After the Future."

  • Fabian Muniesa's 'Paranoid Finance' on the overlaps of mainstream financial thought, the culture surrounding crypto bros etc., and conspiratorial thinking.​​

  • Institute of Network Cultures longform pieces on nostalgia. Tropey stuff like discussing backrooms with Baudrillard.

  • The whole anti-hauntology thing, (mostly people mourning -- a response)​​

​​

image.png
  • Instagram
bottom of page