AYU WHITMORE
TELLING STORIES
TELLING STORIES

TELLING STORIES




Photograph © Vogue Germany, Sebastian Kim. Featuring Magdalena Langrova.
Minimalism isn't the only trademark of designer branding-- haute couture has turned destitiution aesthetic, swaddling models in material madness. Slavik, a homeless man from Ukraine, became a street fashion icon who's innovative approach of layering scavenged clothes paved the way for streetwear. Thrifted pieces were appropriated by Balenciaga, selling the style for thousands. Vogue Germany's editorial entitled 'Signs of the Time' features a similar eclectic amalgamation of designer brands paradoxically representative of economic failure. Slavik recieved no credit for inspiring the "haute homeless" aesthetic that is essentially a repackaging of poverty for the elite- what was born from marginalised necessity became a fashionable pose. Just as Rothko's minimalist canvases can only be accessed by people with cultural capital, haute homelessness is meaningful only to those who can afford to cosplay poverty.
WORKSHOP 1
Smelling Stories
Our first workshop tasked us to (as a group) design the packaging/bottle of an unlabelled perfume and envision a character likely to use it, an approach that encouraged us to consider characterisation from an entirely different lens, or rather sense, that being smell.
Packaging allows us to distinguish high and low end products as branding supersedes quality in importance, commodities are detached from labour and material sourcing. Think Tiffany & Co.'s signature blue box - consumers see luxury and commodities are reduced to status symbols, boxes that have no utility beyond aesthetics add perceived value that helps justify extortionate prices. Stripping the product of the casing had us design something based purely off its original function without bias.
Our general consensus was that our vial smelt vile, having an unpleasantly artificial chemical quality to it. We designed a character, a standard middle-aged bloke putting in minimal effort for a date, spritzing the first cheap eau de toilette he spotted in the clearance aisle while checking out in Primark. The packaging is unassuming and aggressively plain to appeal to the traditional macho-posturing men who are affronted by bright and "effeminate" colours on their purely practical cosmetics.
We weren't that surprised to discover the mystery perfume was Byredo Blanche, a popular fragrance priced at £150 for 50ml. Statistically it was unlikely all of us were nose-blind, the reveal reinforced the idea of commodity fetishism - the mythical value ascribed was the sensation of aspirational exclusivity in possessing a designer label. What we all concluded was cheap was high-end, without the visual presentation we compared it to Febreeze. I even came across a website featuring perfume dupes that featured a knock-off of Byredo Gypsy Water, stating "The bottles look similar too, so you could even pass it off as the real thing while it sits on your dressing table."
It all echoes criticisms of contemporary art, abstract pieces indistinguishable from a child's scribbles being auctioned for millions under influential names. Some exploit this embroilment in their work-- Maurizio Cattelan's infamous Comedian (2019) triggered waves of art discourse, a banana duct-taped to a wall selling for $120,000 (≈£90,900). Baudrillard's sign value, economic counterpart to the dichotomy of Marx's exchange-value vs. use-value, is clear here: in a consumer-oriented society, value is not intrinsic but symbolic, derived from cultural capital. Simplicity becomes a mark of sophistication, the banana visually minimal like Byredo packaging.

Photograph © Rhona Wise/EPA, Maurizio Cattelan’s Comedian.

© Lionsgate Television. (Mad Men).
This isn't to say contemporary art is simply a vehicle for capital the way name-brand products are - creatives like Rothko revolutionised art by rejecting literal representation, rejecting earlier forms of art that functioned as a symbol of status and relied on patronage from elitist institutions. Abstract expressionism has a similar approach as branding, minimalistic designs that focus on creating a shared emotional experience. Comedian challenges the viewer as a consumer, art reflecting the market transcends mere fetishism, the absurdity of the banana parodies its very condition of art-as-commodity. Whether or not this simplification of visual language has become a new form of aesthetic elitism, only to be appreciated by the educated, remains highly contested.
This workshop emphasised the importance of what visual design can indicate. The imagery I create doesn't exist in a vacuum, it is a cultural product operating within systems of ideology and value. In the context of packaging design, the tiniest details can distinguish one as gauche from exclusive, and an inherent classism governs who decides what is considered such.
Moving forward I will consider the social implications of the images I create, what my storytelling adopts or critiques, and whether the narrative seduces the audience or exposes that seduction. The audience is not passive, and I should consider how I want the reader to consume my story, as well as what that consumption says about them, or about culture.
Following the same 'less is more' logic of brand packaging, and abstraction Rothko employed to inspire such an emotional response with abstraction, I want to epxlore conveying a narrative without such literal representation.
To establish my direction I dissected some of my favourite critically acclaimed entertainment (A Clockwork Orange (1971) and Succession (2018)), identifying the common denominators and convergences in narrative (philosophical foundations & thematic meaning) and analysing visuals.
Stanley Kubrick's magnum opus A Clockwork Orange (1971), film adaptation of Anthony Burgess' 1962 dystopian novel, explores the tension between free will and social conditioning through state reforms: when the ability to choose wrongdoing is psychologically removed, can a person be truly good without the freedom to be evil? The Ludovico Technique, a fictional aversion therapy the anti-hero Alex undergoes, parallels B.F. Skinner’s operant conditioning, a learning process that controls behaviour through consequences. Burgess presents this logic as flawed and dehumanising throughout the narrative similarly to Kantian ethics - moral worth can only be determined through free thought, and the conditioning reduces man to machine: “When a man cannot choose, he ceases to be a man.” Utilitarianism may bring about happiness for the most; but strips one of autonomy and justifies authoritarian control, behaviourism may reflexively socially-condition a person into morality; but coerced goodness is meaningless, especially to Burgess who was Roman Catholic, and who's moral framework was based on repentance, sin and choosing between good and evil.





After Alex jumps from a window to escape his state of being unable to act on his impulses, his treatment is undone to avoid political scandal, leaving him to exclaim "I was cured alright!". Cured of the cure, a happy ending, as while his impulses have returned he agrees to not act upon them, albeit incentivised through bribery, becoming the successful hypocrite of society the government (that was more concerned about making crime rates appear reduced than actually preventing it) wanted. Genuine morality is irrelevant, the ending showing how society is more irredemable than Alex.
Thematically, it's the search for meaning from Alex after becoming a moral automaton that interests me, Burgess' clear opposition to state-enforced reformation brings to question Alex's purpose after being stripped of free-will. Alex and the state are presented as as bad as each other, both seeking control, albeit one through instinct and the other through system. The lack of a cohesive style throughout reflects Alex's arc, beginning with wide angled lenses, dolly shots, and garish pop and baroque futuristic design; creating a sense of unreal. Kubrick's mise-en-scène aestheticizes violence into absurdity while classical music plays, juxtaposing the barbarity. Alex's time in prison is far more muted, desaturated colours and slow camera movements reflective of his subdued mind. Yet there is consistency in the setting being a bleak dystopian futurescape both in and outside of prison; the avant-garde mix of brutalist architecture and kitsch, classical music and synthesisers, and provocative fashion make for a far more interesting setting than the cliché sci-fi totalitarian state who's individualistic hero "escapes the matrix". Instead we're confronted with a protagonist who is refreshingly irredemeable in a static system.
A similar irony and existentialism is employed in Jesse Armstrong's drama-comedy Succession (2018), particularly within protagonist and anti-hero Kendall Roy. The entirety of the show follows the power struggle between the Roy siblings fighting for CEO position of the family media conglomerate, at the mercy of the patriarch, their father. Parodying the media industry, while A Clockwork Orange critiques authoritarian governance, Succession ridiculues capitalism through Kendall's performative PR progressivism, the narcissism of nepo-babies (one of whom ran for president, while having no conventional job experience), and sycophantic jesters like cousin "Hey... big fan... of all your money" Greg. Unlike Alex, Kendall is happy to perform, banking all his meaning in succeeding the company; "I am like a cog built to fit only one machine."
Kendall's autonomy is fantastical, as he pendulum swings between vying for his father's approval and staging petty attempts at takeovers. The writing is satirical genius, Shakespearean stakes of legacy and succession undercut with deadpan realist corporate jargon and documentary style filming, making a mockery of the American dream and the myth of meritocracy. As comedian Demi Adejuyigbe put in his viral remix of the theme song, “All the rich white folk are going to argue, and then whoever’s best is going to win a kiss from daddy”.
I believe the best types of characters are the most irredemable ones, and if Succession excels at anything, its at having a truly despisable cast, all smarmy, servile, and voraciously self-interested. At its centre stands a patriarch who despises his children for their privilege, a man whose contempt becomes the founding logic of a dynasty. The result is a brood of narcissists, each a unique reflection of their father’s pathology. Kendall is both addict and hypocrite, a man who conceals a vehicular manslaughter while preaching moral clarity and condemning his father, an embodiment of Nietzsche’s ressentiment: the slave-moralist who condemns in others what he cannot purge in himself. Roman’s crude machismo masks a deep erotic confusion, his masochistic attachment to authority enacting Freud’s repetition compulsion in a corporate frame.




"I am the eldest boy!" Kendall cries, a pathetic last ditch attempt to convince his siblings to vote him in as CEO, less an argument than an echo of a child begging for recognition. Though he ends nominally free, untethered from the company and his father’s shadow, his freedom feels less like liberation than exile. Even with limitless wealth, it remains doubtful he will find happiness in a life beyond the architecture of power that formed him. Even the “clumsy interloper” who inherits the empire is condemned to his victory, a hollow triumph, condemned to the sterile logic of capital. There is no redemption, no catharsis; just like A Clockwork Orange, the system persists with indifference.
Satire & Anti-heroes in Art
Literary analysis
Like Alex in A Clockwork Orange they are all subjects of late-capitalist conditioning, creatures who in their very depravity reveal how thoroughly choice has been scripted. Their cruelty and vanity are not rebellion but the most human gestures left within a mechanized moral order.

Our Narratology workshop underscored the value of deconstructing stories to reuse their elements. Intertextuality is used by even the most successful storytellers, but there is a fine line distinguishing homage from imitation. Denis Villeneuve states he took significant inspiration from the "masterclass" cinematography of David Lean’s 1962 epic Lawrence of Arabia when creating his Dune adaptations (2021, 2024). Like in Lawrence of Arabia, they used 70mm wide-screen cinematography to make the Arrakis desert feel immense. Drawing from Brutalist architecture, ancient Ziggurats, and contemporary Arab architecture, Villeneuve formed a distinctive style that ensured when drawing from classics, the material is refracted through his unique vision.
Narratology



To end off the workshop we were told to draw a 3 page comic in just a couple minutes. With not much time to think about the concept I settled on a, at first glance, cute story between old-lady and her pet cat that quickly takes a disturbing (cannibalistic) turn. I'm used to thoroughly planning pieces, even simplistic satirical cartoons, so this was a challenge, and the perfectionist in me dislikes the drawings, but for something done in such a short time I'm satisfied. When we took a look at eachother's comics mine was highlighted as morbidly surprising and humorous, I'd say I achieved what I set out for, and the reaction I got from such a simple strip shows it was effective.
I enjoyed this quick and simple sequential way of presenting a story, and may revisit it as a format.
We were tasked to capture a defining scene in one of our favourite films in just three shots. I chose a sequence from the black comedy film Four Lions (2010). Cinematography wise, it purposefully switches between our main characters to their friend blowing himself up by accident. The same composition captures their expressions showing the transition between joshing and genuine horror. No words are exchanged, the silence speaks for itself, and the result is hilarious. It also touches upon the technique frame within a frame, the fence they're peeking through emphasises them peeking through the gap, and Hassan (the character furthest away), not yet clocking onto what has happened, still stupidly smiling.
I thought this sequence was a good example to play with the Kuleshov effect, and experimented altering the middle frame to with change the scene's impact and emotion.
Guest Lecture
We watched a pre-recorded guest lecture by illustrator Lesley Imgart. She challenged us with a storytelling exercise, making a four-panel comic using both text and image to notice what’s been on our minds and communicate it through art.
Three introspective prompts were given to assist us and narrow things down:
- What am I afraid of?
- I feel that something is changing.
- A reminder to myself: . . .

I thought I'd illustrate the idiom 'shooting yourself in the foot', and for the captioning a string of thoughts reflective of a self-sabotaging mentality: "am I paranoid enough?" showing irony. The issue is the comic initally both shows and tells, and so I changed the words to be seemingly unrelated to the images, instead written is the narrator (me) snoozing their alarm and oversleeping. This conveys the idea that long-term self-destructive behaviour manifests in small acts of laziness without a literal drawing of someone snoozing their alarm.




Our thought experiment of the day was to create a character based on a randomly assigned object from one of our lecturers' assortment of tchotchkes.
Our group had been given a wrought iron key.
both emotional
and historical connection
Since I wanted to explore the satire route, I ended up creating a character similar to Succession's Connor Roy. After being randomly given prompts to narrow our stories down,
I tried again, this time trying to convey my struggles with social anxiety. The narwhal "breaks the ice" to encounter the inuits above, a moment preceded by an image of it being torn apart by a polar bear, an allegory for the paralysing fear and percieved threat that some asocial people experience.
Overall I really enjoyed this excersise, it challenged me in thinking how interestingly I can present my perspective with simplistic, metaphorical imagery.
Object workshop
Ada Indonesia coy
I was told by classmates in peer review that it wasn't clear what my direction was, which is understandable since I haven't fully settled on a theme. I'm establishing now that I want to create an image or series of images conveying the volatility of Indonesia's political climate, and the inner conflict. Living in England, I know people have been typically ignorant to the multiple huge protests that occurred in 2025 and had cities in flames, opposed to the regime and elites. The theme in the brief that most obviously aligns with this would be "control". Mainstream media rarely covers corruption in the global South that isn't a Western-backed proxy war.
I enjoyed the absurd satire of A Clockwork Orange and Succession, and writing about a self-interested elite in our object workshop. I'm using these as inspration to inform how I express the ridiculousness of Indonesia's corruption.
I follow the account Propagandapolis on multiple social media apps. They archive and share real posters of propaganda art, which convey stories, conflicts, and ideologies satirically, without the literal intricacies and mundanity of politics.



I've done research on OSPAAAL for a different project, so immediately I thought of Rostgaard and his iconic folding poster of Nixon. The poster is effective at simply, simple and a clear villainzing caricature. And so I remade it with Indonesia's infamous President Prabowo.
.avif)

I know I did a good job as I showed this to my Indonesian mother and she got very serious and said I couldn't post this anywhere (especially not the internet) otherwise the government would barr me from ever going back to Indonesia.
For the transitionary page in the middle I scribbled "INDONESIA GELAP" over Prabowo, meaning "Dark Indonesia" a popular hashtag online among Indonesians protesting.
None of the people I know who saw this knew who this man was, Prabowo isn't well known outside Maritime South East Asia. I knew I had to not illustrate actual figures in politics.
Reasons dfor protest aren't clear unless you're familiar with the #IndonesiaGelap movement told rather than a commentary on Prabowo also.

APPLYING INTERTEXTUALITY
Allegory (Brechtian distance) Postcolonial critique via traditional form Kamasan as non-perspectival time

Brainstorming and narrowing down, Rather than creating one propaganda styled illustration, I'd like to create a sequence of images telling a story of conflict within Indonesia while leaving out the intricacies of the politics, taking inspiration from Banshees of Insherin. This introduces people who have no idea of Indonesia's political climate to the turbulece through a singular relationship, more accessible than an image with references that will only be understood by Indonesians. Being that I'm English and want to tell a story to other English speakers.
I though to include komodo dragons and for it to be set on Komodo island, as they are recognised outside of south east Asia. This would appeal to a broader audience.
-- The Act of Killing (Filmmakers expose the horrifying mass executions of accused communists in Indonesia and those who are celebrated in their country for perpetrating the crime.) I watched for insider perspective
-- Revolusi (book (talk about specifically eco-tourism and progress vs tradition inner conflict)
In Banshees of Insherin, there is allegorical Distance: The central, petty conflict between Pádraic and Colm is widely interpreted as an allegory for the Irish Civil War (1922-1923), which is constantly referenced by gunshots and smoke on the mainland. This creates distance by forcing the audience to see the personal conflict as a reflection of broader political, historical, and nationalistic, rather than just emotional, trauma. I uses absurdist/surreal Action like a Clockwork Orange: The extreme, almost surreal, and violent nature of Colm's self-mutilation (cutting off his own fingers) acts as a shocking interruption to the naturalistic drama, demanding the viewer analyse the character's motivation (desperation, depression, and artistic obsession) rather than simply empathizing with his pain. The characters also function somewhat as archetypes, representing different facets of Irish identity (e.g., the "nice" conformist, the tortured artist, the tragic youth). This, too, mirrors Brechtian techniques of using characters to represent larger social forces.



Image 1: BALANCE
Two rangers stand next to each other. One komodo rests near them. The island is intact.
Pre-conflict equilibrium.
Image 2: THE AGREEMENT
Gold Ranger receives a scroll (treaty). Money bags thrown his way. Stone Ranger turns head away, crosses arms. Komodo sniffs the scroll. Island cracks appear. Foreign development enters, fracture begins.
Image 3: IMITATION
Rangers argue from other sides of island (Banshees of Insherin, utilising gap between) using mirrored gestures. Komodos now stand upright. Resorts are being constructed, environment harmed. Two komodos fight in the exact same pose as the men. One komodo wears a torn human accessory. Nature absorbs human violence, parodying it.
Image 4: KOMODO ISLAND (65–90s)
Ranger of Stone cooking ranger of Gold, Komodos destroy construction sites, dance, stand and talk to each other, wear hard hats, burst water pipes, and occupy both sides, frolicking together. They repeat the same argumentative gestures as the humans. The island collapses. One komodo turns head to look at us, breaking the 4th wall, looking at us, licking its own eyeball. Black with circle masked that zooms into the face.
Without explanation, this thematically shows Indonesia’s political contradiction through two similar men claiming opposite futures, Eco-capitalism, Absurd tragedy, and Banshees of Insherin energy through stubborn silence and ritualized hostility.
The Komodos are made peculiar through mimesis, not plot. Wearing human clothes, mirroring poses; it reads instantly.
Contrast of old kamasan artstyle with modern elements as "progress" comes in.
The Komdos and island fighting back is in a way representative of the ways Indonesia's geography hasn't complied with humanity, such as Jaakarta sinking, an absurd scenario.
KAMASAN & JAVANESE ART

Tableau & Tableau Vivant Traditions. Tableau is literally a “living picture.” In theatre and art, gestures, static poses, and dramatic composition convey narrative without motion or perspective depth.
Medieval and Renaissance narrative panel painting communicates story through arranged flat scenes, often sequential.
.avif)

RISOPRINTING
I didn't like the image when I finished it digitally, but when I risoprinted it it looked more unified.
The colours available aren't what I would've personally chosen, so I altered them digitally using gradient maps into a more Indonesian colour scheme.










