Contemporary Issues in Illustration Essay

From Theory to Play: How Disco Elysium demonstrates the potential of speculative fiction and videogames to translate political thought beyond academia
Educational and institutional inequalities contribute to differences in how political ideas are encountered and understood, with political acumen therefore remaining unevenly distributed (ONS, 2020). As sociologist Pierre Bourdieu argues, “The capacity to see (voir) is a function of the knowledge (savoir)… that one has,” (1984, p. 2) suggesting access to education and cultural capital shapes how political reality is perceived. Data from the 2016 United Kingdom European Union membership referendum further demonstrates this divide, with approximately 70% of voters without formal qualifications supporting Leave, compared to most degree holders supporting Remain (British Election Study, 2016). Such disparities help explain the appeal of populist politics, which construct an oppositional “us vs them” narrative that simplifies complex social realities. As philosopher Ernesto Laclau puts it, “the ‘people’ is not a datum, but the result of a political construction” (2005, p. 224).
This reflects a contradiction within leftist theory: while seeking to represent the working class, it has often remained confined to privileged academic spaces, detached from the very class it aims to articulate. This tension is already present in Karl Marx’s distinction between a class “in itself” and a class “for itself,” in which shared material conditions do not automatically produce political consciousness (1847). As Antonio Gramsci later argues, “all men are intellectuals, but not all men have in society the function of intellectuals” (1971, p. 9), highlighting the structural separation of theoretical production from everyday life.
Research in narrative persuasion suggests individuals often incorporate information from fiction into their real-world beliefs, regardless of its fictional status (Green and Brock, 2000; Strange and Leung, 1999). This essay argues that speculative fiction, an umbrella term for narratives that depart from empirical reality, offers a means of bridging the divide between theory and everyday experience, having the potential to shape political attitudes as much as non-fiction material, and that game worlds, in particular, function as theoretical spaces capable of refiguring political thought. In videogame Disco Elysium (ZA/UM, 2019), speculative fiction becomes participatory, and political theory is shifted from an abstract domain into an accessible, embodied, decision-driven experience.
Speculative Fiction and Ideology
Speculative fiction has long been entangled with ideology. Nineteenth-century speculative fiction often reflected imperial expansion, as authors such as H.G. Wells and Jules Verne imagined technological futures shaped by European ambition, while colonial “lost race” narratives framed the unknown as a terrain for conquest (Rieder, 2008). Besides entertaining, these works naturalised dominant ideological frameworks. Contemporary speculative fiction, however, increasingly turns toward critique. Works such as The Dispossessed (Le Guin, 1974) explore the structural inequalities of capitalism, while The Man in the High Castle (Dick, 1962) examines complicity within authoritarian regimes. Across media, speculative fiction remains a mirror of social reality: often revelatory and never neutral, it is shaped by its historical conditions. Imagined worlds thus remain historically situated, carrying the weight of real political conditions while opening up space for alternative possibilities.
This critical capacity is theorised by academic Darko Suvin through the concept of cognitive estrangement. For Suvin, speculative fiction is not defined by fantasy but by its grounding in cognition, producing new ways of understanding social reality by presenting worlds that are both unfamiliar and rationally plausible. Central to this is the novum, the element that distinguishes the fictional world from reality through which existing social structures can be re-examined (1979). By displacing political ideas into imagined contexts, speculative fiction creates critical distance, allowing contentious issues to be engaged with outside the constraints of immediate political partisanship. As author Javier Padilla argues, science fiction is “not simply an object of theory but a mode of theorising in its own right” (2022), dissolving the boundary between narrative and philosophical discourse. Through the construction of worlds, speculative fiction functions as a form of popular epistemology where knowledge is encountered beyond academia.
In this context, videogames extend this capacity further by transforming theoretical engagement into interactive experience. Scholarship has tended to focus on how virtual worlds represent and amplify our own world back to us (Deibert 1997, cited in Castro and Kiersey, 2021). As Thomas Matthew Payne argues, institutions like the U.S. Army develop game worlds that encourage players to find joy in war, normalising the moral perspective of Western military power (2016). Against this backdrop, Disco Elysium offers a uniquely estranged perspective on world politics that unsettles dominant Anglo-American frameworks and undermines the binary opposition between a coherent “West” and a subordinated “Rest”. As the game was developed by Estonians who grew up under the USSR, it resists reductive or essentialist readings of colonial identity, and instead, through defamiliarized worldbuilding, stages an anti-essentialist confrontation between local leftist and dominant Western perspectives.
Disco Elysium as Theory
It is within this framework that Disco Elysium can be understood as a contemporary extension of speculative fiction’s theoretical potential. Developed by ZA/UM, a collective of writers, artists, and political thinkers turned game studio, the role-playing game places the player in the role of Harry Du Bois, a detective who awakens from a drinking binge with no memory, navigating both a murder investigation and a fractured political landscape.

Set in the decaying district of Martinaise (see Figure 1), within the city-state of Revachol, the game constructs a world shaped by the aftermath of failed revolution and decades of subsequent occupation by the Coalition, an international governing body, situating Revachol within a system in which local governance is replaced by technocratic administration, stripped of autonomy. Lead writer Robert Kurvitz notes, “any truly believable world not only has but is history,” (Kurvitz, 2020). In Disco Elysium, history is not resolved but stalled: the environment itself becomes a material record of political failure, aligning with Henry Jenkins’ concept of “narrative architecture,” (2004) where meaning is conveyed through spatial design. Dilapidated infrastructure, muted industrial palettes, and visible poverty communicate the persistence of economic decline and social fragmentation. Here, Revachol embodies Jacques Derrida’s notion of hauntology, a landscape haunted by unrealised futures where the remnants of revolution persist as spectral traces (1993). The game presents a world in which history continues to shape the present, but without the promise of progress, echoing Mark Fisher’s concept of capitalist realism, in which the persistence of neoliberalism forecloses the possibility of imagining alternatives (2009).


The game’s worldbuilding is clearly informed by Marxist-Hegelian thought, with “Mazovian Socio-Economics” functioning as an analogue for Marxist political economy grounded in what the game explicitly refers to as historical materialism. However, rather than presenting a linear progression of historical stages, the transition from feudalism to neoliberal capitalism is compressed, and temporal layers coexist. Some characters dress in nineteenth-century working-class attire (see Figure 2), aside infrastructure of globalised trade, such as shipping containers in the docklands (see Figure 3), suggesting a collapse of historical continuity. In contrast to the optimistic trajectory of Marxist historiography, no definitive proletarian victory is anticipated by the general populace, rejecting teleological optimism. As character Joyce Messier observes, “capital has the ability to subsume all critiques into itself” (ZA/UM, 2019), suggesting those who critique capital end up reinforcing it instead.
This cynical condition is both systemic and psychological. Harry Du Bois’ mental deterioration reflects both individual trauma and broader social collapse, illustrating the interdependence of material conditions and subjective experience. The game is distinctly postmodern in its exposure of the solipsism at the heart of ideology, collapsing the boundary between the personal and the political, echoing Fisher’s argument that experiences such as depression and anxiety are inseparable from the conditions of late capitalism. By placing the player within this fractured subjectivity, the game transforms abstract political critique into affective experience. Research in narrative persuasion suggests engagement with fiction can produce measurable increases in empathy, as readers, or players, become immersed in and identify with characters (Green and Brock, 2000). Thus, speculative fiction has the capacity to reshape political perception and what rights one believes they should and do possess, as as research in narrative persuasion suggests, individuals may internalise ideas encountered in fiction (Strange and Leung, 1999).
Interactivity and Political Understanding
Crucially, this engagement is not only representational but interactive. Bettina Bódi contends videogames construct meaning through player interaction with designed environments (2022), and in Disco Elysium, this logic is realised as the player’s exploration and decision-making allows the game’s political themes to emerge gradually through spatial experience.

Despite the game’s reliance on text, mechanics differentiate it from a conventional visual novel. The protagonist’s skills manifest as competing internal voices, shaping perception and influencing interactions (see Figure 4). Ideological positions such as communism, fascism, and liberalism function as gameplay systems, allowing players to “level up” dispositions and experience their consequences. Rather than reading dense theory, users navigate ideology through choices and consequences, making complex concepts intuitive. Craig Hayden discusses how videogames simulate political systems through the design of player choice, transforming abstract political relations into interactive processes (cited in Castro and Kiersey, 2021). In Disco Elysium this takes the form of a fragmented political landscape in which no single ideology is presented as completely coherent. In contrast to Ernesto Laclau’s account of populism as the construction of a unified “people” (2005), the game resists simplification. There is no unified group: workers are divided, institutions such as the union are corrupt, and ideological positions are depicted as historically contingent and internally contradictory. Political thought is therefore encountered as complexity rather than reduced to binary oppositions.
This mode of engagement can be understood through the concept of rhizomatic learning, developed by Dave Cormier and informed by Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari’s notion of the rhizome, in which knowledge is constructed through non-linear exploration rather than hierarchical instruction. (Cormier, 2008; Deleuze and Guattari, 1987) Videogames therefore display the potential in facilitating a decentralised form of learning in which players actively construct political understanding, transforming politics into an interactive experience without trivialising ideology.
Disco Elysium as Manifesto

Towards the end of the game, speculative, supernatural elements take on explicit political significance. The murderer is revealed to be a disillusioned communard deserter, isolated and believing the revolution is still ongoing, yet the more significant revelation is the subsequent encounter with the Insulindian Phasmid, a “cryptid” (see Figure 5) that had long been dismissed as mythological.
The Pale, a spreading anthropogenic force described as a form of psychic anti-matter that erodes both reality and memory, composed of degraded “past information,” functions as a materialisation of historical trauma and the collapse of future possibility. It embodies a hauntological condition in which the past overwhelms the present, representing nihilism and the inability to imagine a future. Harry’s debilitating state parallels this, being unable to move on, blotting out his past, and giving up on life; a microcosm of how the world ends, the death of the new. In contrast, the Insulindian Phasmid appears as an antithesis to the Pale: proof that the unimaginable can still exist, representative of the persistence of the unknown, suggesting that alternative futures remain possible despite apparent stagnation.
This opposition of collapse and possibility reflects the game’s broader political logic. While acknowledging the failures of revolutionary movements, it resists pessimism and maintains the hope for the possibility of change, highlighting the urgency in looking forwards rather than backwards. Hinted at the end of the game, an event known as “the Return” alludes toward the possibility of an incoming revolution reestablishing self-governance in the city, so long as Harry, and all other Revacholians, are vigilant, and persist. Author China Miéville discusses how fantasy can expose the absurdity of reality by making the impossible feel coherent (2002, 39-49), and the game reasserts the possibility of alternatives, even within a world seemingly dominated by inertia where change seems unfeasible, suggesting that history, though stalled, is not closed.


Following the game’s climactic tribunal, minor character Cindy the Skull sprays-paints “Un jour je serai de retour près de toi,” (One day I will return to your side) onto the site where blood was spilled (see Figure 6). The gesture and aesthetic echoes Situationist détournement, transforming the environment into a space of political expression. The phrase evokes a nostalgia for unrealised futures while asserting the persistence of revolutionary hope that refuses extinction, and the impact of Disco Elysium’s quotes extends beyond the game itself, fans having reproduced the imagery through tattoos (see Figure 7) and graffiti (see Figure 8).

It is a testament to how the revolutionary visuals and thought have circulated in real-world contexts, Disco Elysium’s philosophy of resisting the capitalist symptom of depressive anhedonia being enacted. It is evident here that speculative narratives can operate as “prophetic truths,” mobilising collective imagination rather than merely conveying objective reality. In this regard, Disco Elysium operates as a form of interactive manifesto, using its myth-like narrative to expose the contradictions of political systems and inviting players to engage with them critically, while inspiring creative output; its audience, in a sense, attempting to enact a “Return” of their own.
Conclusion
What Disco Elysium ultimately reveals is not simply that videogames can communicate political ideas, but that they can reshape how those ideas are encountered altogether. Rather than presenting theory as something to be learned, the game embeds it within the textual political strife, systems to be navigated, and failures to be confronted. The limitations of academic theory become apparent in its lack of accessibility to those without privileged access to education, as well as its relative absence of the emotional resonance needed to move audiences into action beyond abstract analysis.
If, as Karl Marx suggests, material conditions do not automatically produce political consciousness (1847), then Disco Elysium offers an alternative model: one in which consciousness emerges through experience and affect. The player is not instructed in ideology but implicated within it, forced to confront its inconsistencies rather than resolve them.
Deuteragonist Kim Kitsuragi’s reflection that “every school of thought and government has failed in this city — but I love it nonetheless” (ZA/UM, 2019) is neither an endorsement of failure nor a retreat into cynicism, but an acknowledgement that political belief persists even in the absence of certainty. Even within the constraints of a commercialised videogame industry, Disco Elysium not only articulates theory to a broader audience but reconfigures the conditions under which theory becomes meaningful at all. What emerges is a participatory politics that extends beyond academia, not only to be understood but felt, and lived.
Bibliography
BÓDI, B., 2022. Videogames and Agency (Edition 1). Taylor and Francis.
BOURDIEU, P. and NICE, R., 1984. Distinction : a social critique of the judgement of taste. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
BRITISH ELECTION STUDY, 2016. EU Referendum Results by Education.
CASTRO, V. and KIERSEY, N.J., 2026. The world politics of Disco Elysium. London ; New York: Routledge.
CORMIER, D., 2008. Rhizomatic Education: Community as Curriculum. Innovate (North Miami Beach, Fla.), 4 (5).
DEIBERT, R.J., 1997. Parchment, printing, and hypermedia : communication in world order transformation. New York: Columbia University Press.
DELEUZE, G., GUATTARI, F. and MASSUMI, B., 1987. A thousand plateaus : capitalism and schizophrenia. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
DERRIDA, J., 1993. Spectres of Marx. Paris: Éditions Galilée.
FISHER, M., 2009. Capitalist realism. Winchester ; Washington: Zero Books.
GRAMSCI, A., HOARE, Q. and NOWELL-SMITH, G., 1971. Selections from the prison notebooks of Antonio Gramsci. London: Lawrence & Wishart.
GREEN, M.C. and BROCK, T.C., 2000. The role of transportation in the persuasiveness of public narratives. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 79 (5), 701–721.
JENKINS, H., 2004, Game Design as Narrative Architecture. In: Game Design as Narrative ArchitectureFirst Person: New Media as Story, Performance, and Game. United States: MIT Press, 2004, .
KURVITZ, R., 2020, Designing the World of Disco Elysium. In: Designing the World of Disco ElysiumDisco Elysium Art Book. Los Angeles, USA: iam8bit, 2020, .
LACLAU, E., 2005. On populist reason. 1. publ. ed. New York [u.a.]: Verso.
MARX, K., The Poverty of Philosophy [online]. Available at: https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/download/pdf/Poverty-Philosophy.pdf [Accessed Apr 3rd 2026].
MAXGIVINGHEADROOM, 2024. Photograph of a tattoo of the Star-and-antlers.
MIÉVILLE, C., 2002. Editorial Introduction. Historical Materialism, .
OFFICE FOR NATIONAL STATISTICS (ONS), 2020. Civic Engagement and Political Participation in the UK.
PADILLA, J., Science Fiction as Theory Fiction [online]. Available at: https://modernismmodernity.org/forums/posts/padilla-science-fiction-theory-fiction [Accessed Apr 3rd 2026].
PAYNE, M.T., 2016. Playing War. New York: New York University Press.
RIEDER, J., 2008. Colonialism and the emergence of science fiction. 1st ed. Middletown, Conn: Wesleyan University Press.
ROSTOV, A., Sunset over Jamrock Quarter (Eminent Domain). Disco Elysium Art Book.
ROSTOV, A. and ZA/UM, Insulindian phasmid photo art.
STRANGE, J.J. and LEUNG, C.C., 1999. How Anecdotal Accounts in News and in Fiction Can Influence Judgments of a Social Problem’s Urgency, Causes, and Cures. Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin, 25 (4), 436–449.
SUVIN, D., 1979. Metamorphoses of science fiction : on the poetics and history of a literary genre. New Haven: Yale University Press.
SZANKAJS, Disco Elysium graffiti found in Wrocław [online]. Available at: https://www.reddit.com/r/DiscoElysium/comments/1pyv4zx/another_disco_elysium_graffiti_found_in_wroc%C5%82aw/?share_id=jD-3_dsGvBVjkNiSgAgNw [Accessed Mar 29th 2026].
SZANKAJS, 2025b. Photograph of graffiti quote from Disco Elysium in Wrocław.
VILL, A., Revolutionaries. Disco Elysium Art Book.
ZA/UM, 2019. Disco Elysium. London
ZA/UM, The Docklands. Disco Elysium Art Book.
ZA/UM and CUMMINGS, N., Screenshot from Disco Elysium “Un Jour Je Serai de Retour Près de Toi”.
ZA/UM and TOMS, O., Set skill screen screenshot from Disco Elysium.
Feedback & grade

Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed researching and writing this essay. Although balancing it alongside my other work was challenging at times, much of the research fed naturally back into the illustration work I was producing across other modules.
If it is not already clear, I feel very strongly about Disco Elysium and deeply admire the original ZA/UM collective behind it. Their work demonstrated how art and storytelling can genuinely affect people’s lives, and that is something I aspire to achieve, even in some small way, through my own practice in the future.



Comments